My favorite part of the Fresno Philharmonic program on Saturday was the Shostakovich Symphony No. 9. To think that the subversive composer twisted this "celebratory" symphony -- meant to laud the Soviet victory over Nazi Germany in World War II -- into an impish, sardonic exercise that really ticked off Stalin is a hoot. When the trombones took off with their ominous theme midway through the piece, I thought of a huge, glowering mug of the Dear Leader staring down with disapproval, but not quite able to purge the popular Shostakovich. In the last movement, I loved how an excited Kuchar drove the orchestra forward almost as if he were a chariot driver cracking a whip. Such passion and spitfire enthusiasm seemed to infect the players, and I think everyone's pulse rate in the Saroyan rose slightly.
I thought it was sweet, too, the way Kuchar acknowledged the soloists for the piece, asking bassoonist Larry Gardner to stand and shaking his hand. Perhaps it was just coincidence that the gesture was so personal, but it also was a symbolic nod toward the tentative agreement that had been struck the night before between the orchestra's management and musicians union, of which Gardner is the president.
As for the raging Rachmaninoff Piano Concerto No. 3, or famed "Rach 3," played by young Czech soloist Lukas Vondracek, I just didn't connect with the music. To me the experience was impressive technically, I guess, but only in a bombastic, blustery way -- and for most of the piece I never felt a soul-stirring immersion in the experience. I admit that I've never felt much love toward the "Rach 3." It requires a hurricane-gale dose of virtuosity, but I can't dredge up much more than clinical admiration toward the end result.
George Warren of MusicCriticFresno.com offers his take on the concert.
Any Philharmonic-goers care to share their impressions? Leave a comment on this post.





I was impressed with the whole concert experience. Fortunate to be able to attend both Saturday's and Sunday's performances (due to my solo art exhibit being featured in the lobby for the weekend), I was particularly impressed with the enthusiasm every musician, solo and as the entire orchestra had for the work. And Lukas was amazing in his talent with the Rach 3. I do greatly enjoy this music and was thrilled to be able to see/hear it performed live. Added to the performance also was the genuine enthusiasm from the audience! Bravos all around!